Lots of Collectibles That Are Hard to Find!

Indian Penny

Indian Penny

Looking for Americana at competitive prices? Looking for Americana or relevant listings? We promote a large variety of Indian Penny, plus listings such as Mechanical Bank, Wind Up Toy, Pez, Diecast, plus lots more. Shop our extensive collection, or try a simple search for a more specific Indian Penny using the site search. Our site has access to thousands of items from retailers, so our site just might have what you're trying to locate! Purchase Indian Penny now!

Indian Penny

1896 Pf65 Proof Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Monster Toned Gorgeous Colors
1896 Pf65 Proof

1896 Pf65 Proof Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Monster Toned Gorgeous Colors

Buy Now!
$1999.99
 1871 Ms64 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye-appeal
1871 Ms64

1871 Ms64 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye-appeal

Buy Now!
$1999.95
 1898 Pf66 Rb Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Proof Example
1898 Pf66

1898 Pf66 Rb Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Proof Example

Buy Now!
$1999.95
 1883 Ms66 Rb Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye-appeal
1883 Ms66

1883 Ms66 Rb Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye-appeal

Buy Now!
$1999.95
1886-p Variety 2 Two Indian Head Penny Cent 1c Pcgs Ms 63 Red Rd Rare High Grade
1886-p Variety 2

1886-p Variety 2 Two Indian Head Penny Cent 1c Pcgs Ms 63 Red Rd Rare High Grade

Buy Now!
$1950.00
 1908-s Ms65 Bn Pcgs Cac Indian Head Penny Premium Quality And Eye Appeal
1908-s Ms65

1908-s Ms65 Bn Pcgs Cac Indian Head Penny Premium Quality And Eye Appeal

Buy Now!
$1899.95
 1870 Ms64 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye-appeal
1870 Ms64

1870 Ms64 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye-appeal

Buy Now!
$1899.95
 1864 L Ms64 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye-appeal
1864 L

1864 L Ms64 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye-appeal

Buy Now!
$1899.95
 1908 Pf66 Rb Ngc Indian Head Penny Proof Example Superb Eye-appeal
1908 Pf66

1908 Pf66 Rb Ngc Indian Head Penny Proof Example Superb Eye-appeal

Buy Now!
$1899.95
 1901 Pf66 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Proof Example
1901 Pf66

1901 Pf66 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Proof Example

Buy Now!
$1899.95
 1898 Pf66 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Proof Example
1898 Pf66

1898 Pf66 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Proof Example

Buy Now!
$1899.95
1895/895 Indian Head Cent/penny Rare Snow-pr5 Finest Known Blazer Ngc Pf 66 Bn
1895/895 Indian Head

1895/895 Indian Head Cent/penny Rare Snow-pr5 Finest Known Blazer Ngc Pf 66 Bn

Buy Now!
$1895.00
Indian Head Cent/penny 1877 Key Date Vf With Iron Cross Countersamp
Indian Head Cent/penny

Indian Head Cent/penny 1877 Key Date Vf With Iron Cross Countersamp

Buy Now!
$1877.00
1877 Indian Head Penny Pcgs Vf25 Problem Free Wonderful Details 🔥🔥1c
1877 Indian Head

1877 Indian Head Penny Pcgs Vf25 Problem Free Wonderful Details 🔥🔥1c

Buy Now!
$1875.99
 1906 Pr66 Bn Pcgs Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Proof Example
1906 Pr66

1906 Pr66 Bn Pcgs Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Proof Example

Buy Now!
$1799.95
Indian Head Penny Complete Set 38 Coins With Full Liberty
Indian Head Penny

Indian Head Penny Complete Set 38 Coins With Full Liberty

Buy Now!
$1790.00
Indian Head Penny Complete Set 29 Coins With Full Liberty
Indian Head Penny

Indian Head Penny Complete Set 29 Coins With Full Liberty

Buy Now!
$1760.00
Complete Indian Head Penny
Complete Indian Head

Complete Indian Head Penny

Buy Now!
$1750.00
 1867 Ms65 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye-appeal
1867 Ms65

1867 Ms65 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye-appeal

Buy Now!
$1749.95
 1903 Ms66+ Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye-appeal
1903 Ms66+

1903 Ms66+ Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye-appeal

Buy Now!
$1749.95
Indian Head Penny Complete Set 27 Coins With Full Liberty
Indian Head Penny

Indian Head Penny Complete Set 27 Coins With Full Liberty

Buy Now!
$1740.00
Indian Head Penny Complete Set 20 With Full Liberties
Indian Head Penny

Indian Head Penny Complete Set 20 With Full Liberties

Buy Now!
$1710.00
1877 1c Ngc Vf30 Indian Head Cent Penny, Key Date
1877 1c Ngc

1877 1c Ngc Vf30 Indian Head Cent Penny, Key Date

Buy Now!
$1699.99
 1888 Pf66 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Proof Example Superb Eye-appeal
1888 Pf66

1888 Pf66 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Proof Example Superb Eye-appeal

Buy Now!
$1699.95
 1887 Pf66 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Proof Example Superb Eye-appeal
1887 Pf66

1887 Pf66 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Proof Example Superb Eye-appeal

Buy Now!
$1699.95
1877 Indian Head Penny Pcgs F-15 King Of The Indians
1877 Indian Head

1877 Indian Head Penny Pcgs F-15 King Of The Indians

Buy Now!
$1699.00
1877 Indian Head Cent Penny -- Make Us An Offer E0459
1877 Indian Head

1877 Indian Head Cent Penny -- Make Us An Offer E0459

Buy Now!
$1688.00
1905 Indian Head Cent/penny Rare Pop 19/5 Magnificent Purple Blazer Ngc Pf 66 Bn
1905 Indian Head

1905 Indian Head Cent/penny Rare Pop 19/5 Magnificent Purple Blazer Ngc Pf 66 Bn

Buy Now!
$1684.00
Indian Head Penny Complete Set 18 Coins With Full Liberty
Indian Head Penny

Indian Head Penny Complete Set 18 Coins With Full Liberty

Buy Now!
$1680.00
1867/67 Indian Head Cent/penny Re Punched Date Very Scarce Error Fs-301/snow 1
1867/67 Indian Head

1867/67 Indian Head Cent/penny Re Punched Date Very Scarce Error Fs-301/snow 1

Buy Now!
$1680.00
1864 Pcgs Pr64 Copper Nickel Indian Head Penny 1c
1864 Pcgs Pr64

1864 Pcgs Pr64 Copper Nickel Indian Head Penny 1c

Buy Now!
$1650.00
1870 Indian Head Penny, Pik-axe Fs-303 Snow-7 Mint Error
1870 Indian Head

1870 Indian Head Penny, Pik-axe Fs-303 Snow-7 Mint Error

Buy Now!
$1630.00
 1884 Pf66 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Proof Example
1884 Pf66

1884 Pf66 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Proof Example

Buy Now!
$1599.95
1897 Toned Pf66 Rb Proof Indian Head Penny - Stunning Pr Cent - Ngc Graded
1897 Toned Pf66

1897 Toned Pf66 Rb Proof Indian Head Penny - Stunning Pr Cent - Ngc Graded

Buy Now!
$1575.00
1909s Indian Head Penny High Grade
1909s Indian Head

1909s Indian Head Penny High Grade

Buy Now!
$1550.00
1862 Proof Indian Head Penny Cent Ngc Pf62 Civil War Era
1862 Proof Indian

1862 Proof Indian Head Penny Cent Ngc Pf62 Civil War Era

Buy Now!
$1550.00
1863 Indian Head 1c Cent Copper Nickel Penny
1863 Indian Head

1863 Indian Head 1c Cent Copper Nickel Penny

Buy Now!
$1500.00
1877 Indian Head Cent Penny 1c 4 East Coast Coin And Collectables, Inc.
1877 Indian Head

1877 Indian Head Cent Penny 1c 4 East Coast Coin And Collectables, Inc.

Buy Now!
$1499.99
Indian Head Cent/penny 1870 Snow-8 Digits In The Denticles Variety R7
Indian Head Cent/penny

Indian Head Cent/penny 1870 Snow-8 Digits In The Denticles Variety R7

Buy Now!
$1499.99
1899 Indian Head Penny Small Cent Copper Proof Coin Ngc Pf65 Rb Cameo Red Brown
1899 Indian Head

1899 Indian Head Penny Small Cent Copper Proof Coin Ngc Pf65 Rb Cameo Red Brown

Buy Now!
$1499.99
1879 Indian Head Penny Pr66rb Pcgs
1879 Indian Head

1879 Indian Head Penny Pr66rb Pcgs

Buy Now!
$1499.99
 1867 Pf64 Rb Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Proof Example
1867 Pf64

1867 Pf64 Rb Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Proof Example

Buy Now!
$1499.95
 1873 Ms64 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Monster Toning
1873 Ms64

1873 Ms64 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Monster Toning

Buy Now!
$1499.95
 1902 Pf65 Rd Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Proof Example
1902 Pf65

1902 Pf65 Rd Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Proof Example

Buy Now!
$1499.95
1908-s Indian Head Penny
1908-s Indian Head

1908-s Indian Head Penny

Buy Now!
$1499.00
1890 Indian Cent Penny Variety Error Anacs Ms63 Red Rd Fs-010.85 Fs-101 Tdo Wow
1890 Indian Cent

1890 Indian Cent Penny Variety Error Anacs Ms63 Red Rd Fs-010.85 Fs-101 Tdo Wow

Buy Now!
$1460.03
1898 Indian Head Penny Appears A Wonderful Gem+ Red @@ Exceptional @@
1898 Indian Head

1898 Indian Head Penny Appears A Wonderful Gem+ Red @@ Exceptional @@

Buy Now!
$1447.23
1891 Indian Head Cent/penny Very Rare Plus Slab Ultra Low Pop 3/6 Ngc Ms 65+ Rb
1891 Indian Head

1891 Indian Head Cent/penny Very Rare Plus Slab Ultra Low Pop 3/6 Ngc Ms 65+ Rb

Buy Now!
$1422.00
1877 Indian Head Penny Cent Anacs Graded Vg 10 Key-date
1877 Indian Head

1877 Indian Head Penny Cent Anacs Graded Vg 10 Key-date

Buy Now!
$1399.99
 1888 Pf65+ Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Proof Example
1888 Pf65+

1888 Pf65+ Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Proof Example

Buy Now!
$1399.95
 1865 Ms65 Rb Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye Appeal
1865 Ms65

1865 Ms65 Rb Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye Appeal

Buy Now!
$1399.95
1889 1c Ms65bn Anacs- Repunched Date- Nice Indian Head Penny
1889 1c Ms65bn

1889 1c Ms65bn Anacs- Repunched Date- Nice Indian Head Penny

Buy Now!
$1350.00
 1890 Ms66 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye-appeal
1890 Ms66

1890 Ms66 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye-appeal

Buy Now!
$1349.95
1922 Penny Indian Obverse Ngc Ms62bn
1922 Penny Indian

1922 Penny Indian Obverse Ngc Ms62bn

Buy Now!
AU $1899.95
1888 Indian Head Cent/penny Wild Purple Tones Scarce Ngc Mint State 65 Red Brown
1888 Indian Head

1888 Indian Head Cent/penny Wild Purple Tones Scarce Ngc Mint State 65 Red Brown

Buy Now!
$1314.00
1871 1c Unc Key Date Nat.toning Indian Head One Cent, Us Coin Penny, Scarce
1871 1c Unc

1871 1c Unc Key Date Nat.toning Indian Head One Cent, Us Coin Penny, Scarce

Buy Now!
$1299.99
 1883 Ms66 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye-appeal
1883 Ms66

1883 Ms66 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye-appeal

Buy Now!
$1299.95
 1908 Ms66 Rb Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye-appeal
1908 Ms66

1908 Ms66 Rb Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye-appeal

Buy Now!
$1299.95
 1900 Ms66 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Monster Toning
1900 Ms66

1900 Ms66 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Monster Toning

Buy Now!
$1299.95
 1894 Pf65 Rb Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Proof Example
1894 Pf65

1894 Pf65 Rb Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Proof Example

Buy Now!
$1299.95
1909-s Indian Head Cent Penny Choice Bu Red 2
1909-s Indian Head

1909-s Indian Head Cent Penny Choice Bu Red 2

Buy Now!
$1295.00
1909-s Indian Head Cent Penny Choice Bu Red
1909-s Indian Head

1909-s Indian Head Cent Penny Choice Bu Red

Buy Now!
$1295.00
1909-s Pcgs Au58 Indian Head Cent Penny 1c Us Coin Item 29819a
1909-s Pcgs Au58

1909-s Pcgs Au58 Indian Head Cent Penny 1c Us Coin Item 29819a

Buy Now!
$1294.95
1899 Indian Head Penny
1899 Indian Head

1899 Indian Head Penny

Buy Now!
$1285.00
1882 Indian Head Cent/penny Amazing Beauty Very Rare Monster Blazer Ngc Pf 66 Bn
1882 Indian Head

1882 Indian Head Cent/penny Amazing Beauty Very Rare Monster Blazer Ngc Pf 66 Bn

Buy Now!
$1284.00
1888 Indian Head Cent/penny Rare Pop 58/7 Magnificent Choice Blazer Ngc Pf 66 Bn
1888 Indian Head

1888 Indian Head Cent/penny Rare Pop 58/7 Magnificent Choice Blazer Ngc Pf 66 Bn

Buy Now!
$1284.00
1883/3 Indian Head Cent/penny Scarce Snow-pr5 Finest Known Blazer Ngc Pf 66 Bn
1883/3 Indian Head

1883/3 Indian Head Cent/penny Scarce Snow-pr5 Finest Known Blazer Ngc Pf 66 Bn

Buy Now!
$1284.00
1873 Doubled Die Obverse Indian Cent Penny Fs-102 Ddo. Ngc Uncirculated Unc Ms
1873 Doubled Die

1873 Doubled Die Obverse Indian Cent Penny Fs-102 Ddo. Ngc Uncirculated Unc Ms

Buy Now!
$1278.17
1869 Indian Head Cent/penny Very Scarce Semikey Date Pcgs Ms 63 Red Brown Beauty
1869 Indian Head

1869 Indian Head Cent/penny Very Scarce Semikey Date Pcgs Ms 63 Red Brown Beauty

Buy Now!
$1248.00
1863/863 Indian Head Cent/penny Cn Rare Snow 7 Finest Known Gorgeous Ngc Ms 64
1863/863 Indian Head

1863/863 Indian Head Cent/penny Cn Rare Snow 7 Finest Known Gorgeous Ngc Ms 64

Buy Now!
$1248.00
Indian Head Penny 1902
Indian Head Penny

Indian Head Penny 1902

Buy Now!
$1200.00
1867 1c Pcgs Pr64 Rb Proof Indian Head Penny, Red Brown
1867 1c Pcgs

1867 1c Pcgs Pr64 Rb Proof Indian Head Penny, Red Brown

Buy Now!
$1199.99
Indian Head Cent/penny 1877 Key Date Liberty
Indian Head Cent/penny

Indian Head Cent/penny 1877 Key Date Liberty

Buy Now!
$1199.99
 1894 Ms66 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye-appeal
1894 Ms66

1894 Ms66 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye-appeal

Buy Now!
$1199.95
 1899 Pf65 Rb Ngc Indian Head Penny Proof Example Superb Eye-appeal
1899 Pf65

1899 Pf65 Rb Ngc Indian Head Penny Proof Example Superb Eye-appeal

Buy Now!
$1199.95
 1889 Pf65 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Proof Example Superb Eye-appeal
1889 Pf65

1889 Pf65 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Proof Example Superb Eye-appeal

Buy Now!
$1199.95
 1886 Type 1 Ms65 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality
1886 Type

1886 Type 1 Ms65 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality

Buy Now!
$1199.95
Flying Eagle And Indian Head Cent Complete P Mint Penny Collection Album 1857-1909
Flying Eagle And

Flying Eagle And Indian Head Cent Complete P Mint Penny Collection Album 1857-1909

Buy Now!
$1197.95
1900 Indian Head Cent Penny Ngc Ms 66 Rb Red/brown Mint State Certified
1900 Indian Head

1900 Indian Head Cent Penny Ngc Ms 66 Rb Red/brown Mint State Certified

Buy Now!
$1195.00
1869 Ngc Ms-62 Red / Brown Indian Head Cent Penny W9073
1869 Ngc Ms-62

1869 Ngc Ms-62 Red / Brown Indian Head Cent Penny W9073

Buy Now!
$1188.00
1883 Indian Head Cent/penny Amazing Very Rare Monster Purple Blazer Ngc Pf 66 Bn
1883 Indian Head

1883 Indian Head Cent/penny Amazing Very Rare Monster Purple Blazer Ngc Pf 66 Bn

Buy Now!
$1184.00
1908 S Indian Head Cent Penny 1c Pcgs And Cac Ms 64 Rb Mint Unc - Red Brown 137
1908 S Indian

1908 S Indian Head Cent Penny 1c Pcgs And Cac Ms 64 Rb Mint Unc - Red Brown 137

Buy Now!
$1149.92
1877 Indian Head Penny Anacs Graded F 15
1877 Indian Head

1877 Indian Head Penny Anacs Graded F 15

Buy Now!
$1145.00
1873 Closed 3 Indian Head Penny Ngc Ms64 Rb
1873 Closed 3

1873 Closed 3 Indian Head Penny Ngc Ms64 Rb

Buy Now!
$1100.00
 1903 Ms66 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Monster Toning
1903 Ms66

1903 Ms66 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Monster Toning

Buy Now!
$1099.95
 1874 Ms65 Rb Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye-appeal
1874 Ms65

1874 Ms65 Rb Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye-appeal

Buy Now!
$1099.95
 1896 Ms65 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Monster Toning
1896 Ms65

1896 Ms65 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Monster Toning

Buy Now!
$1099.95
 1909 Ms66 Rb Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye-appeal
1909 Ms66

1909 Ms66 Rb Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye-appeal

Buy Now!
$1099.95
 1886 T2 Ms64 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye-appeal
1886 T2

1886 T2 Ms64 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Superb Eye-appeal

Buy Now!
$1099.95
 1866 Pf64 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Proof Example
1866 Pf64

1866 Pf64 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Premium Quality Proof Example

Buy Now!
$1099.95
1892 Indian Head Cent/penny Rare Pop 16/1 Magnificent Choice Blazer Ngc Pf 66 Bn
1892 Indian Head

1892 Indian Head Cent/penny Rare Pop 16/1 Magnificent Choice Blazer Ngc Pf 66 Bn

Buy Now!
$1084.00
1872 Indian Head Cent/penny Awesome Magnificently Monster Toned Gorgeous Beauty
1872 Indian Head

1872 Indian Head Cent/penny Awesome Magnificently Monster Toned Gorgeous Beauty

Buy Now!
$1080.00
1857-1909 Flying Eagle And Indian Head Penny 56 Coin Set Collection
1857-1909 Flying Eagle

1857-1909 Flying Eagle And Indian Head Penny 56 Coin Set Collection

Buy Now!
$1075.00
Near Complete58 Coins Indian Head Penny Album. 2 Coin 09s And 77 Not Included
Near Complete58 Coins

Near Complete58 Coins Indian Head Penny Album. 2 Coin 09s And 77 Not Included

Buy Now!
$1075.00
1866 1c Pcgs Pr64 Rb Cac Proof Indian Head Penny - Red Brown
1866 1c Pcgs

1866 1c Pcgs Pr64 Rb Cac Proof Indian Head Penny - Red Brown

Buy Now!
$1049.99
1877 Indian Head Penny Coin Rare
1877 Indian Head

1877 Indian Head Penny Coin Rare

Buy Now!
$1000.00
1901 + 1902 Indian Head Cents - Penny 1c Coins
1901 + 1902

1901 + 1902 Indian Head Cents - Penny 1c Coins

Buy Now!
$1000.00
Anacs Au55 Indian Head Penny Off Center 50 Wow
Anacs Au55 Indian

Anacs Au55 Indian Head Penny Off Center 50 Wow

Buy Now!
$1000.00
1868 1c Pcgs Pr64 Rb Cac Proof Indian Head Penny, Medal Alignment, Red Brown
1868 1c Pcgs

1868 1c Pcgs Pr64 Rb Cac Proof Indian Head Penny, Medal Alignment, Red Brown

Buy Now!
$999.99